Welcome to zdnet’s diy-it project lab, in which i am pressure-testing raid devices in your leisure and edification. In this newsletter, we’ll be looking at the first of seven nas products to look how it performs.
permit’s placed this venture into context. The whole cause of a raid is that if a pressure fails, you may get better and not using a facts loss. In this collection, i’m pounding on each nas to peer how (or if) it recovers.
almost all the nas evaluations available simply communicate approximately including garage, and the diverse apps that include the devices. I have not seen any that strain the machines to the point of failure and back to restoration, that is the entire factor of these devices.
i have subjected every candidate system to a sequence of torture tests. Beyond that, i look at performance, apps, consumer interface, and so much greater. This challenge has been huge. Genuinely doing actual checking out on the storage stage has been pretty time ingesting. There was a factor in which i used to be involved i might never, ever finish. However here we are.
the benchmark case for all seven raids is drobo. When a pressure is going horrific with a drobo, a large red light turns on. It is feasible, from throughout the room, to peer the status of the gadget at a glance.
considering that 2009, i’ve sold 4 drobos, three that are directly connected to my predominant computer, and one drobo 5n nas, the predecessor to the tool we are checking out nowadays. The capacity to see the reputation of my drobos just by taking walks into the room has established invaluable.
in my remoted study/write checks, the new drobo 5n2 writes 24 percentage faster than the 5n, and reads nearly 10 percent quicker. The 5n2 additionally provides a 2nd ethernet port. The authentic 5n i bought in 2014 most effective had one ethernet port.
by comparison, all of our 2017 take a look at candidates now include ethernet ports. Drives are also extraordinary smooth to install. They don’t require any trays, brackets, or screws. They just slide right in.
my successful reports detecting and improving from quite uncommon pressure failures with my older drobos is my benchmark for this a part of the take a look at, so it comes as no marvel that the 5n2 exceeded both the failure discovery and notification checks with flying colours.
all the other nas packing containers took at least six minutes to identify the terrible pressure, and one failed absolutely. By means of comparison, the drobo 5n2 took less than a minute to come across the awful power, and flashed a huge crimson led.
the drobo has massive leds you may see from throughout the room. You can also see, at a glance, universal array capability due to the row of blue lights along the lowest of the unit. Drobo makes use of its personal service for email notification, so you do not want to fight your isp’s smtp forwarding regulations.
after a replacement force turned into inserted, the drobo did an automated rebuild of the replacement drive and reallocated garage to permit boom over time. Increase-over-time is a key check that not all of the nas containers exceeded. The drobo performed perfectly.
for raid performance and information safety, the drobo earned a super 5 out of five stars.
it’s difficult to examine costs on our seven nas bins due to the fact i used to be despatched machines ranging from 2 to eight bays. I determined to apply a price-consistent with-bay metric to determine how every machine in comparison to all the others.
given the high best suit and end of the drobo, i used to be surprised to find that it had the lowest rate in line with bay, at nearly exactly $one hundred each.
other than the rate boost and the introduced ethernet port, the brand new drobo 5n2 is quite plenty indistinguishable from the drobo 5n i purchased from amazon again in 2014. Whilst drobos are very well designed units, the truth that the design hasn’t changed a whole lot presents a problem.
in contrast to each other nas i tested, the drobo would not provide a web interface. You need to install an application on your gadget (which ought to be a mac or windows gadget — linux users want now not follow).
you even have to reboot your laptop after putting in the dashboard, which i assume makes experience for the direct-attached drobos however is totally useless to speak to a community tool.
the drobo dashboard offers a long way fewer bells and whistles than the other storage arrays. As an instance, you can’t do something with stocks apart from create them and assign permissions. Period. The drobo also misplaced factors because it does not offer a community recycle bin. In case you delete a file on the drobo nas, it is long gone.
in terms of apps, the drobo is within the middle of percent. It has greater apps than a number of our contenders, but a ways fewer than synology and qnap. Additionally, some of the apps are rather abnormal to apply.
for example, to apply crashplan, you have to additionally deploy a crashplan controller app on every other device and hand edit its ini document to factor to the drobo. On every occasion crashplan updates, you need to go returned in and re-edit that ini report. It is ugly, annoying, inconvenient, and unreliable.
as i stated earlier, study/write performance at the 5n2 become hugely superior to the earlier 5n. But in comparison to all of the different nas bins i tested, it changed into close to the lowest of the p.C..
so where does that leave us? On one hand, suit and finish and the physical construct is nearly perfect. However, the dearth of a modern-day web interface, the lack of a community recycle bin, and the rather low comparative overall performance led to a mediocre usability and overall performance rating of best 3 out of 5 stars.
that said, if you need a competitively-priced storage appliance in which all you do is slide in drives and files are served, the drobo is a win. Average, the drobo earned a four out of five stars.
this is it for these days. Stay tuned. We have six extra nas opinions coming, plus a wrap-up wherein i’ll take you backstage to discuss method and evaluate all seven devices facet-by way of-side.
you could follow my everyday undertaking updates on social media. Be sure to comply with me on twitter at @davidgewirtz, on fb at fb.Com/davidgewirtz, on instagram at instagram.Com/davidgewirtz, and on youtube at youtube.Com/davidgewirtztv.